Message-ID: <f146ca66-a611-f129-ae11-6907a7333d10@b10c.me>
Date: Fri, 9 Dec 2022 17:04:05 +0100
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Language: en-US
To: Anthony Towns <aj@erisian.com.au>,
 Bitcoin Protocol Discussion <bitcoin-dev@lists.linuxfoundation.org>
References: <Y2I3w8O5X55sD/3C@petertodd.org> <Y2qc7Ubc5xtJhxGw@petertodd.org>
 <Y3MlSE7AWkBgiCyr@erisian.com.au>
From: 0xB10C <b10c@b10c.me>
In-Reply-To: <Y3MlSE7AWkBgiCyr@erisian.com.au>
Content-Type: multipart/signed; micalg=pgp-sha256;
 protocol="application/pgp-signature";
 boundary="------------el0cjU0JiDDiwilLXQvdOJOZ"
Subject: Re: [bitcoin-dev] Announcement: Full-RBF Miner Bounty
Precedence: list

This is an OpenPGP/MIME signed message (RFC 4880 and 3156)
--------------el0cjU0JiDDiwilLXQvdOJOZ
Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="------------QyK1ViLYVcHpNjDVgBhB1h0M";
 protected-headers="v1"
From: 0xB10C <b10c@b10c.me>
To: Anthony Towns <aj@erisian.com.au>,
 Bitcoin Protocol Discussion <bitcoin-dev@lists.linuxfoundation.org>
Message-ID: <f146ca66-a611-f129-ae11-6907a7333d10@b10c.me>
Subject: Re: [bitcoin-dev] Announcement: Full-RBF Miner Bounty
References: <Y2I3w8O5X55sD/3C@petertodd.org> <Y2qc7Ubc5xtJhxGw@petertodd.org>
 <Y3MlSE7AWkBgiCyr@erisian.com.au>
In-Reply-To: <Y3MlSE7AWkBgiCyr@erisian.com.au>

--------------QyK1ViLYVcHpNjDVgBhB1h0M
Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="------------F2JDS0oZSoOEEMyXRk0nw9EZ"

--------------F2JDS0oZSoOEEMyXRk0nw9EZ
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

Hi AJ and list,

> This seems to be pretty good evidence that we currently don't have any
> significant hashrate mining with fullrbf policies (<0.5% if there was a=

> high fee replacement available prior to every block having been mined),=

> despite the bounty having been collected.

For further monitoring, I've set-up a mempoolfullrbf=3D1 node and are
logging replacement events with [0]. I filter the full-RBF replacements
and list the replaced and replacement transactions here:

https://fullrbf.mempool.observer/

This also tries to find out if either the replaced or replacement
transaction has been included in a block upon loading the site. The
yellow mined-in-badges link to the block on miningpool.observer to a)
show the mining pool (if known) and b) see if the (mempoolfullrbf=3D0)
miningpool-observer node thinks this transaction is extra / conflicts
with the mined transaction. This should be the case if a full-RBF
replacement transaction is mined.

Over the last few days, I has mostly seen OP_RETURN transactions
(presumably mostly by OpenTimestamps; but I haven't checked closely) and
a few other non-OP_RETURN transactions. None of the replacement
transactions have been mined yet.

[0]: https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/26531#issuecomment-133383290=
6

Best,
0xB10C

--------------F2JDS0oZSoOEEMyXRk0nw9EZ
Content-Type: application/pgp-keys; name="OpenPGP_0x188CBB2648416AD5.asc"
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="OpenPGP_0x188CBB2648416AD5.asc"
Content-Description: OpenPGP public key
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
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=3DgC4N
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

--------------F2JDS0oZSoOEEMyXRk0nw9EZ--

--------------QyK1ViLYVcHpNjDVgBhB1h0M--

--------------el0cjU0JiDDiwilLXQvdOJOZ
Content-Type: application/pgp-signature; name="OpenPGP_signature.asc"
Content-Description: OpenPGP digital signature
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="OpenPGP_signature"

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

iQIyBAEBCgAdFiEEDMuq/Xai7OLM0xQd4v/VsdiMqX0FAmOTXHUACgkQ4v/VsdiM
qX1LCw/4jKw9Dgh6vL7pu89Vt+ZE25JmFoA8t8bqE4fDrdBMRsycFOSR73y3t6R6
xlLcE1TW5rVFIp5WJqOQinJ/zDRT5GwwZa7eDw78+cE1kCw/LT3TvJ8jJaWdV+OM
uFVJF6MrNI2IZh3r3SSRZnghH/jWrgPBs3u8Z4D1BL6Ae/QtQt02jqJRVPkgvQnf
mu7QkepdLBQn24ZziDDC9G019Ds98GklDamOX1oi3eInFouex7/rQRdM4Zl+F1RL
Nm2yApie+lcnxAXpKQoPsQmvNzqPBEwYpbA/EWSFlpjUQGExSsx3ib8LJfulwl1w
7wNpcLwWMvaR3nV93vbdvQdv1BtmmQUthm3SxGOJNdx7QBEcvRYQsI9A7DioPLG2
riCBFGUvAB34M8VQ71lecJMEKbAGHtbSKZQIHUSsH5TpK7Yqz1NNqyIWr0NmFRdG
j5OWkdTP4XKBGstRmkOQsZnqCh0oQZs8+5gsIpfGO+DNtIk6FdK3l7k/RRScp8TR
RpskJANCGFP6RSM82EBuCYITG9G2tIKP/k2dLoTGdWAKJx778ts5FnpMdT/8knv9
V+Up3x3d4E61iY0PXFrOitb8xwt3LRRElgx2JMg0QKKKlER6xumjd6UsOijDnUXl
mNZtMcqr2awaIC1PrRgme00R3hlgTTdIuahGwaQooay7fBsZpA==
=GWla
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--------------el0cjU0JiDDiwilLXQvdOJOZ--